Equities fair value models; Forward P/E
By Gareth David HoweAcutis Capital Founder
What are investors paying for expected company earnings? These research charts compare the S&P 500 and all eleven sectors using forward price-to-earnings ratios: Technology (XLK), Health Care (XLV), Financials (XLF), Energy (XLE), Utilities (XLU), Consumer Staples (XLP), Consumer Discretionary (XLY), Industrials (XLI), Materials (XLB), Real Estate (XLRE) and Communication Services (XLC). Also included are Semiconductors (SMH), Russell 2000 small caps (IWM), Emerging Markets (EEM) and a memory/storage test proxy for DRAM using MU and WDC.
Forward P/E divides an index’s price by consensus expected operating earnings over the next twelve months. A lower multiple means paying less for those expected earnings—not necessarily a better investment. These approximate sector-index histories are proxies for the named ETFs, not the ETFs’ own historical forward P/E records.
- SPY adjusted close
- $754.37
- P/E implied value
- $711.11
- Latest deviation
- +0.31 SD
- Saved through
- 13 Nov 2026
Forward P/E proxy ≈18.3× · Historical mean 17.3× · SD 3.4×. P/E history 07 Jan 1998–13 Nov 2026; ETF prices from 02 Jan 1998. Source: published sector/index forward P/E charts; chart-digitised, approximate dates and values.
SPY · forward P/E implied value
Forward P/E multiple · historical mean and ±1 SD
9 Nov 2016 – 13 Nov 2026 · 555 approximate source observations
Relative value ranking
Value rank: most undervalued → most overvalued · latest saved model deviations · approximate forward P/E proxies
| 1 | ≈8.4× | — | ≈11.5× | -3.1× | -2.00 | -26.7% | $60.92 | $83.12 | |
| 2 | ≈11.6× | ≈0.18 | ≈19.1× | -7.5× | -1.00 | -39.4% | $486.75 | $802.77 | |
| 3 | ≈36.4× | ≈1.49 | ≈40.1× | -3.7× | -0.64 | -9.1% | $44.37 | $48.83 | |
| 4 | ≈17.2× | ≈0.44 | ≈21.8× | -4.6× | -0.58 | -21.1% | $170.28 | $215.88 | |
| 5 | ≈8.9× | — | ≈11.6× | -2.8× | -0.56 | -23.7% | 5534.73 pts | 7252.86 pts | |
| 6 | ≈12.2× | ≈0.69 | ≈16.6× | -4.4× | -0.55 | -26.3% | $64.96 | $88.17 | |
| 7 | ≈22.5× | — | ≈22.5× | -0.0× | -0.00 | -0.1% | $270.98 | $271.16 | |
| 8 | ≈17.0× | ≈1.04 | ≈17.0× | -0.0× | -0.00 | -0.0% | $108.69 | $108.70 | |
| 9 | ≈18.3× | ≈0.76 | ≈17.3× | +1.0× | +0.31 | +6.1% | $754.37 | $711.11 | |
| 10 | ≈17.5× | ≈1.08 | ≈16.4× | +1.1× | +0.37 | +6.5% | $52.23 | $49.03 | |
| 11 | ≈19.8× | ≈1.40 | ≈17.3× | +2.5× | +0.54 | +14.6% | $188.85 | $164.79 | |
| 12 | ≈16.9× | ≈1.86 | ≈15.4× | +1.5× | +0.57 | +9.6% | $44.04 | $40.19 | |
| 13 | ≈24.9× | ≈1.43 | ≈20.6× | +4.3× | +0.84 | +20.6% | $119.98 | $99.49 | |
| 14 | ≈15.2× | ≈1.15 | ≈13.2× | +2.0× | +1.09 | +14.9% | $58.68 | $51.06 | |
| 15 | ≈22.2× | ≈1.23 | ≈17.5× | +4.7× | +1.40 | +26.8% | $168.78 | $133.08 | |
| 16 | ≈23.6× | ≈2.57 | ≈18.4× | +5.2× | +1.93 | +28.3% | $92.35 | $71.98 |
As of: 30 Oct 2026 / 5 Nov 2026 / 13 Nov 2026
DRAM’s test row ranks the MU / WDC proxy against its own available forward P/E history. Price and implied value are stock-index points, not ETF dollars; its sparse, cyclical history differs from sector coverage. PEG remains unavailable without matching growth estimates.
The forward P/E model
Each series has its own historical average forward P/E and standard deviation. The price-equivalent model value is the selected ETF’s dividend-adjusted price multiplied by the historical average P/E, divided by its sector or index proxy’s observed forward P/E. The price bands use the average multiple minus or plus one standard deviation.
This translates a relative earnings valuation into an illustrative ETF price, not a forecast or an independently estimated intrinsic value. Sector-index membership, weighting and earnings aggregation differ from the ETFs. Digitisation adds approximate dates and values; obscured or missing source observations are omitted rather than invented. Earlier P/E observations can appear without ETF prices, especially for Real Estate and Communication Services.
PEG divides forward P/E by consensus expected annual earnings growth over the next five years, expressed in percentage points. All eleven S&P 500 sectors and the S&P 500 use matching sector-index growth estimates from LSEG Datastream, published by Yardeni Research on 13 November 2026, alongside P/E observations dated the same day. Sector earnings-growth source. These remain approximate index proxies, not ETF-specific PEG ratios. A dash means matching growth estimates are unavailable or not positive. Hovering a PEG reading shows its growth estimate and source date. PEG does not change value ranks or model bands.
Deviation and model bands
The lower panel shows the forward P/E multiple, its historical average and ±1 SD levels. Deviation is (observed P/E − average P/E) ÷ standard deviation. Green value is strictly below −1 SD and red is strictly above +1 SD. Value ranks run from most undervalued to most overvalued relative to each series’ own history, with the lowest deviation first by default.
Changing the timeframe or zoom does not recalculate the historical average, standard deviation or latest ranking. Different available histories and structural changes can affect comparisons between sectors.
What this test cannot establish
These are full-sample descriptive valuations. Later observations influence the historical average and bands shown at earlier dates. Historical earnings revisions, reporting delays and point-in-time estimates have not been reconstructed. An apparently cheap multiple can reflect falling earnings expectations, sector changes or genuine investment risk.
Prior-only calculations and out-of-sample tests with verified earnings data are needed before assessing a strategy. No strategy returns are claimed. SMH uses the S&P 500 Semiconductors index, IWM the Russell 2000 index and EEM the MSCI Emerging Markets index as approximate forward P/E proxies. Their histories start where the source becomes available, not in 1998. Russell 2000 source data are monthly before 2006 and weekly thereafter; its clipped 2020 extreme is omitted rather than estimated. Overlapping emerging-market source lines also leave gaps. The dashboard’s gauges, Equities cash rules and model portfolios remain unchanged.
DRAM uses a two-stock forward P/E research proxy, not a historical ETF valuation. MU (Micron) and WDC (Western Digital) each receive half the initial price-index investment; adjusted prices are rebased to 100 on 2 January 1996 and averaged without rebalancing. Forward P/E averages both companies’ positive next-twelve-month consensus multiples. Their published dates differ, so each combined observation uses the latest source reading on or before that date, at most 28 days old; the chart’s readings show both source dates. The displayed history and valuation sample start with continuous coverage on 5 January 2024 and run through the latest dated source reading, without interpolating earnings or looking ahead. Earlier source observations are excluded from this test’s mean and ±1 SD bands. A missing or non-positive source reading immediately leaves valuation blank; observed stock prices continue through those periods. SNDK is excluded because its relisting limits shared history. The shared model calculates full-history mean, standard deviation, implied index value and relative-value rank from the fixed January 2024 onward observations; price values are index points, never pre-launch DRAM ETF prices. WDC’s 2025 separation changes the basket’s business mix. Sparse sampling, asynchronous estimates, cyclical earnings and large historical multiples can distort the average and bands; vendor history is not independently audited for point-in-time revisions. PEG stays unavailable. MU forward P/E source · WDC forward P/E source.

cutis